Open Cell Vs Closed Cell Foam In Metal Buildings: What’s The Difference?

Insulating metal buildings is crucial to maintain their energy efficiency, reduce the cost of heating and cooling, and improve the overall comfort of the occupants. One of the primary insulation options for metal buildings is foam, but not all foam insulation is created equal. In fact, there are two main types of foam insulation: open-cell and closed-cell.

This article will discuss the differences between open cell vs closed cell foam insulation in metal buildings and which option is best for your project.

Open-Cell Foam Insulation

This type of foam insulation is made by mixing a chemical compound with a blowing agent, which causes the mixture to expand and form bubbles. As the bubbles form, they break and leave small pockets of air in the foam, which create the insulation's insulating properties.

The following are some benefits of this type of foam insulation:

1. Cost-effective: Open-cell foam insulation is typically less expensive than closed-cell foam insulation, making it a more cost-effective option for projects with limited budgets.
2. Good acoustic properties: Open-cell foam insulation has excellent acoustic properties, making it an ideal option for buildings that require sound insulation, such as music studios or theaters.
3. Breathable: Open-cell foam insulation is breathable, which allows moisture to escape from the building. This reduces the risk of moisture buildup and mold growth inside the building.
4. Great for filling gaps and cracks: Open-cell foam insulation expands and fills gaps and cracks in the building's structure, making it highly effective at reducing air leakage and heat loss.

However, like many things, open cell does have some drawbacks:

1. Lower R-value: It has a lower R-value, which means it is not as effective at insulating the building. This can result in higher energy costs over the long term.
2. Less durable: It is less durable and can degrade over time. This can lead to a reduction in its insulating properties and a shorter lifespan.
3. Not as strong: It has a lower compressive strength, making it less resistant to damage from impacts or heavy loads. This can make it a less ideal option for buildings subject to heavy foot traffic or equipment.

Closed-Cell Foam Insulation

This type of insulation is made by mixing a chemical compound with a blowing agent, which causes the mixture to expand and form bubbles. As the bubbles form, they remain intact, leaving no air pockets in the foam.

Here are some primary benefits of this type of insulation:

1. High R-value: Higher R-value makes it more effective at insulating the building.
2. Superior moisture resistance: This type of insulation is impermeable to water, which makes it highly resistant to moisture and mold growth. This makes it an ideal option for buildings in areas with high humidity or moisture and for buildings prone to water infiltration.
3. High compressive strength: Closed-cell foam insulation has a higher compressive strength, making it more resistant to damage from impacts or heavy loads. This makes it an ideal option for buildings subject to heavy foot traffic or equipment.
4. Long lifespan: Closed-cell foam insulation has a long lifespan, typically 30 years or more. This makes it a cost-effective option over the long term, as it does not require replacement as often as other types of insulation.

Similar to open cell, closed cell also has a few drawbacks you must consider:

1. Higher cost: This type of insulation is typically more expensive than open-cell foam insulation due to its higher density and greater insulation properties. This can make it cost-prohibitive for some projects, especially those with limited budgets.
2. Not breathable: It is not breathable, which means that it does not allow moisture to escape from the building.
3. Limited expansion: It has limited expansion properties, which means that it may not be as effective at filling gaps and cracks in the building's structure as open-cell foam insulation. This can reduce its overall effectiveness as an insulator.

How to Choose the Appropriate Insulation

Choosing the proper insulation for your metal building is crucial to ensuring it is energy-efficient, comfortable, and durable. When selecting insulation, consider factors such as climate, building usage, budget, and local building codes.

Closed-cell foam insulation is ideal for buildings in areas with high humidity or moisture, as well as for buildings that will be subject to heavy foot traffic or heavy equipment. Open-cell foam insulation is a cost-effective option for buildings that require sound insulation, such as music studios or theaters. Ultimately, the right insulation option will depend on your building project's unique needs and requirements.

Visit our website now to check our brochure or contact us for an estimate!